Training a German Shepherd: Challenges and Fixes
Disclosure: this guide mentions a training program we're an affiliate for. If you buy through our link we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes our advice. Read our disclosure.
Short answer
German Shepherds were developed from herding breeds and are now the preferred dog of police and military units, according to the AKC. VCA calls them confident and protective, and warns that without proper training they may become overprotective or reactive. Training them means early, careful socialization, daily physical and mental work, and consistent positive reinforcement.
| AKC group | Herding |
|---|---|
| Typical energy | High |
| Common training challenges | wariness and protectiveness, alert barking, restlessness without enough work |
What German Shepherds were bred to do
The AKC explains that German Shepherd Dogs were developed in the late 19th century by Captain Max von Stephanitz, a German cavalry officer, through crosses of older farming and herding breeds. It notes that the breed’s intelligence, agility and air of authority were “forged not in the police academy but in the sheep pasture,” and that the German Shepherd is today the preferred dog for police and military units around the world. VCA describes a breed originally developed for herding and protection that can do anything from service work to companionship.
What that means for training: this is a thinking, working dog with a strong protective streak. VCA describes German Shepherds as confident and protective, especially in unfamiliar situations. Early, careful socialization and a daily job for their minds matter as much as physical exercise.
A German Shepherd in training at a glance
| Trait | What the sources say |
|---|---|
| Energy | 5 out of 5 (AKC); needs lots of exercise for physical and mental well-being (AKC) |
| Mental stimulation needs | 5 out of 5 (AKC); “highly intelligent and need mental stimulation to stay engaged” (VCA) |
| Trainability | 5 out of 5 (AKC); can learn dozens of commands (AKC) |
| Watchdog / protective nature | 5 out of 5 (AKC); may develop overprotective or reactive behaviors without proper training (VCA) |
| Openness to strangers | 3 out of 5 (AKC) |
| Barking | 3 out of 5 (AKC); “moderate” (VCA) |
| Motivators | Consistent positive reinforcement (VCA); small pieces of biscuit or kibble work as treats (AKC) |
| Health points that affect training | Hip and elbow dysplasia and degenerative myelopathy can affect mobility later in life (VCA) |
Typical challenges and a mini plan for each
1. Wariness and protectiveness
The AKC rates the breed 5 out of 5 for protective nature and 3 out of 5 for openness to strangers, and VCA warns that without proper training German Shepherds may become overprotective or reactive.
- Start socialization early: the AKC calls it vital for the breed, and the AVSAB says the first three months are the most important time.
- Let your dog watch new people and dogs from a comfortable distance, and pair what they see with food.
- Never force a greeting; let your dog approach at their own pace.
- Get professional help early if you see growling, lunging or persistent fear of strangers.
Full plans: our puppy training guide (socialization checklist) and the “at other dogs on walks” advice in our barking guide.
2. Alert barking
With a watchdog score of 5 out of 5 (AKC), German Shepherds are quick to let you know something is happening.
- Manage window views while you train.
- Acknowledge the alert, then call your dog away and reward them for coming to you.
- Teach a go-to-mat routine for the doorbell and visitors.
Full plan: our guide to stopping barking.
3. Restlessness without enough work
The AKC warns that a German Shepherd who isn’t exercised enough will become frustrated and likely to develop undesirable behaviors, and VCA says they need mental stimulation to stay engaged.
- Combine physical exercise with a daily training session, so body and brain both get work.
- Add scent games, food puzzles and new cues through the week.
- Consider a dog sport: the AKC recommends agility, herding, tracking and dock diving as excellent physical and mental exercise.
Full plans: our guide to mental stimulation and basic commands guide.
A sample day
This is an example, not a prescription: adjust it to your dog’s age, health and your schedule, and keep training sessions short.
| Time | Exercise | Brain work | Training | Rest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Morning | Brisk walk on leash | Breakfast in a food puzzle | 5 minutes: a new cue | Settle on a mat |
| Midday | ||||
| Afternoon | ||||
| Evening |
Health and safety points that change training
- Joints and mobility. VCA lists hip dysplasia, elbow dysplasia and degenerative myelopathy as key concerns that can affect mobility later in life, and says a healthy weight, regular exercise and routine health screenings support long-term health. The AKC notes responsible breeders screen for these conditions.
- Growing puppies. For large, fast-growing puppies, VCA advises avoiding games that can harm growing bones and joints, and the AKC suggests starting with short daily walks and play sessions in a safely fenced area.
- Off leash. The AKC advises not letting a German Shepherd off leash, since even the best-trained dog can become distracted.
Puppies and adults
The AKC says German Shepherd puppies take well to early socialization and training, and that continuing obedience training helps the pup grow into an adaptable, well-mannered adult. Puppy mouthing and house training follow the same plans as for any puppy; see our guide to stopping biting and house training guide. With adults, keep up both socialization and a daily job for the mind.
Guides that help most with this breed
Frequently asked questions
Are German Shepherds easy to train?
The AKC rates their trainability 5 out of 5 and says they are smart dogs who can learn dozens of commands. VCA says consistent training with positive reinforcement is best.
How much exercise does a German Shepherd need?
The AKC describes a very active, athletic breed that needs lots of exercise for physical and mental well-being, and warns that a dog who isn't exercised enough will become frustrated and likely to develop undesirable behaviors. VCA suggests walking, running and structured training.
Why is socialization so important for German Shepherds?
The AKC calls early socialization and puppy training classes vital for the breed, and VCA warns that without proper training German Shepherds may develop overprotective or reactive behaviors. The AVSAB says the first three months are the most important time for socialization.
Can a German Shepherd be trusted off leash?
The AKC's advice is not to let the dog off leash, noting that even the best-trained dog can become distracted and not follow every command. Practice recall on a long line and use securely fenced areas for free play.
Sources
- German Shepherd Dog breed information — American Kennel Club
- German Shepherd — VCA Animal Hospitals
- Puppy Socialization Position Statement — American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior
- Dog Behavior and Training: Play and Exercise — VCA Animal Hospitals